The Paul Edgerley House stands as one of Brookline’s most iconic luxury residences, blending timeless architecture with elegant modern living. Tucked into an affluent Boston suburb, this 10,350-square-foot estate is a peaceful haven where history meets high-end design. While the estate isn’t officially listed right now, similar homes in the area are priced between $6 million and $12 million, and this one easily falls at the higher end of that scale. Owned by private equity power couple Paul and Sandy Edgerley, the home reflects their refined taste and commitment to preserving architectural beauty. But it’s not just about square footage—this place tells a story, one built on Boston roots, entrepreneurial success, and a clear love for real estate. And when you take a closer look, you’ll see why this property is not just another mansion. It’s a masterpiece.
Who is Paul Edgerley?
Paul B. Edgerley is a name that rings loud in the world of finance. He’s been a managing director at Bain Capital since 1990, and before that, he was a consultant and CPA with Peat Marwick. A Harvard MBA graduate, Paul has long been part of Boston’s financial and philanthropic circles. Together with his wife, Sandy, he co-founded The Quin House, a private social club based in Boston. They’re also behind Hexagon Properties, a real estate venture with a reputation for classy restorations. While Paul handles business on the capital side, Sandy brings creativity and a passion for design, making them a power duo in more ways than one. Their love for restoration and luxury real estate isn’t just a hobby—it’s a shared lifestyle, and it shows in every inch of the Paul Edgerley House.
Paul Edgerley House & Location
Sitting pretty in Brookline, Massachusetts, the Paul Edgerley House is part of a prestigious neighborhood known for historic mansions and privacy. The estate is close to downtown Boston but far enough to offer that tucked-away feel. With leafy streets, top-tier schools, and a real sense of community, Brookline is one of Massachusetts’ most desirable zip codes. This makes the house not just a home but also a prime investment. The couple picked this location strategically, knowing it offers the quiet of suburbia without giving up the perks of city life. Plus, Brookline is known for its elegant old homes, many of which have been modernized while keeping their original soul—something that inspired this one. So, if location is everything, this house already wins.
Features of Paul Edgerley House
- 10,350 square feet of living space
- 10 spacious bedrooms
- 9 modern bathrooms
- Elegant mix of historic and new designs
- Private, upscale Brookline neighborhood
- Customized interior styling
- High-end kitchen and dining areas
- Renovated with luxury amenities
- Gardens and outdoor sitting areas
- Built for both family life and entertaining guests
House Design and Style
The design of the Paul Edgerley House is where old meets new. While it holds onto its historical charm with original moldings, antique woodwork, and classic lines, it also enjoys all the perks of a modern home. The house has a smart layout that makes it feel both grand and cozy. Each room flows naturally into the next, yet still holds its unique personality. The couple’s knack for mixing vintage touches with contemporary upgrades is on full display. From the outside, the house looks like something out of a historic New England postcard. But step inside, and you’ll notice how well it’s adapted to modern tastes—open spaces, lots of natural light, and seamless indoor-outdoor transitions. It’s truly the best of both worlds.
Personal House Touches
Paul and Sandy didn’t just buy a beautiful house—they made it their own. Every detail reflects their personality and lifestyle. The kitchen, for example, isn’t just stylish—it’s practical and built for gatherings. The study has custom-built bookshelves, likely stacked with business books and design magazines. The art on the walls? Many pieces come from local Boston artists whom they support.
Other personal touches include:
- Handpicked antique furniture
- Custom lighting fixtures
- Locally sourced materials for renovation
- A cozy library corner with an original fireplace
- High-tech security system integrated into old structure
- Family room with personalized décor
Interior Design & Highlights
Inside, the Paul Edgerley House feels like an upscale retreat. The interior blends soft neutrals, rich woods, and pops of color for warmth and personality. The living room is spacious yet inviting, while the dining room is formal but never stiff. Bedrooms are large with thoughtful layouts, and each bathroom feels like a spa. The kitchen is the star of the show—big, bright, and full of high-end appliances. There are also hidden gems like a small wine cellar, a reading nook under the stairs, and even a home gym. With every upgrade, the Edgerleys have kept comfort in mind. You can tell it’s a home where people live, not just one that looks good in pictures.
Outdoor House Spaces
Outside, the estate opens up into a peaceful escape. There’s a spacious backyard perfect for kids, pets, or weekend brunches. Trees offer privacy, while small gardens add beauty. A stone patio lets the family entertain under the stars. Even the driveway feels fancy with its circular design and custom gate. This is where nature and luxury play well together. The yard is big but not overwhelming, easy to maintain, and lovely to look at. It’s another sign that this house was built for real life, not just for show.
Market Value and Comparisons
Over the years, the Paul Edgerley House has held its value well. In 2014, Paul and Sandy made headlines by purchasing a different 9,000 sq ft Boston apartment for $17 million. That gives a hint about their taste and spending power. The Brookline estate, larger at 10,350 sq ft, fits right into the top tier of luxury homes in the area. While the house isn’t currently for sale, similar estates in Brookline go for $6 million to $12 million, depending on renovations and location. Given the custom updates and pedigree, this one likely sits close to the top of that range.
Property Pricing Table
| Property Type | Size | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brookline historic estate | 10,350 sq ft | $10M–$12M | Estimated current market value |
| Boston penthouse (Edgerley) | 9,000 sq ft | $17M (2014) | Not the Brookline house |
| Similar Brookline luxury homes | 9–11 beds | $6M–$12M | Market comparisons for 2025 |
Other Houses Owned by Paul Edgerley
Aside from the Paul Edgerley House in Brookline, the Edgerleys have invested in other notable properties:
- Boston Penthouse: 9,000 sq ft apartment bought in 2014 for $17 million
- Aspen “Mountain Forge”: Historic blacksmith shop converted into luxury property; listed for $45 million
- Algonquin Club in Boston: Renovated and transformed into The Quin House, a private social club
- Multiple private equity real estate ventures through Hexagon Properties
Conclusion
The Paul Edgerley House isn’t just real estate—it’s a symbol of taste, success, and smart investing. With 10 bedrooms, 9 bathrooms, and 10,350 square feet of smart design, it’s a home that tells a story. Paul and Sandy Edgerley have put care, class, and personality into every detail, turning a historic property into something truly special. Whether you’re into design, luxury living, or Boston real estate, this house is a standout. Its value has held strong over the years, and it’s likely to remain one of Brookline’s shining stars for decades to come. If homes could speak, this one would whisper luxury and shout legacy.
No Comment! Be the first one.